Amy Tan's writing is beautiful as always. After so many years since her last book, this one began on a high note; then became a chore; then ended abruptly like she ran out of words. When I was six, Mother enrolled me in Miss Jewell's Academy for Girls. A Shanghai courtesan and her madam mother are separated in The Valley of Amazement, the latest multigenerational story from the author of The Joy... A sweeping, evocative epic of two women's intertwined fates and their search for identity, that moves from the lavish parlors of Shanghai courtesans to the fog-shrouded mountains of a remote Chinese village. Amy Tan’s new novel, “The Valley of Amazement,” explores a difficult mother-daughter relationship. Book review. Excerpt courtesy of Ecco, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers. Spanning 50 years in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the saga takes place largely in the courtesan houses of Shanghai, when vast changes were occurring during the early establishment of the Republic of China. The heroine of The Valley of Amazement, Violet, is the daughter of an American madam and a painter. What do you think happens to Violet during the Communist Revolution? I was disappointed in this book but I'm still glad that I read it. Their syllables of gossip and flirtation, complaints and woe went into my ear and came out of my mouth, and in conversations I had with my mother, I had never been told there was anything amiss with my speech. There, It took the better part of 200 pages before this storyline started to gain a stake in my interest, and even then it was more of a gentle tug than a grabber. Violet Minturn, the daughter of a famed American courtesan mistress in Shanghi, is someone I didn't enjoy. Ms Tan was born in the United States to immigrant Chinese parents and her writing often tries to penetrate the unique cultural impact of her parents’ homeland. Violet Minturn is the daughter of the American madam of the city’s most exclusive courtesan house. Harbingers of bad luck masquerade as a sudden breath of wind, a tear in a garment of clothing, or a laughing bird. Her writing is very fluid and strong, so why than did I only rate this book a three? I would predict an Emmy. You could see what was going to happen at the village the second someone said 'oh let's go to my village.' In the first part of the story, Violet tells the story of growing up in Hidden Jade Path, a courtesan house in Shanghai that is run by her mother, an American woman named Lulu Minturn. When I was seven, I knew exactly who I was: a thoroughly American girl in race, manners, and speech, whose mother, Lulu Minturn, was the only white woman who owned a first-class courtesan house in Shanghai. But the worst insult came from an older girl with silly ringlets. They were poignant. What do others think? Violet Minturn, the daughter of a famed American courtesan mistress in Shanghi, is someone I didn't enjoy. Adding to the mess, Mother also spoke Chinese, and her attendant, Golden Dove, also spoke English. I torn between giving this book 3 stars and 3.5 stars. It is a testament to Tan's writing that I finished this book. With sexual content, The Valley of Amazement She was the most interesting character for me. All of which is to say, I had high expectations for this book. Until I went to school, I had been speaking my peculiar language only in Hidden Jade Path to our four courtesans, their attendants, and the servants. 4 stars. They were poignant. “ The Valley of Amazement ” is a novel by Amy Tan, a New York Times bestselling author with magical writing skills. She creeps around the house spying on all the courtesans at work. If you loved MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA, you will be fascinated by the details and lives of Tan's courtesans. The characters that Amy Tan draws for us - strong, savvy and resilient women - would simply NOT turn into nitwits overnight and make the poor decisions she depicts. Alone in the grand bed, like Alice through the looking-glass, I experienced the amazement of finding a whole cosmos inside a book! I'm one of the few people on the planet who didn't much like The Joy Luck Club, but it was Tan's first novel and my reaction had more to do with the way she chose to tell the story than her talent as a writer. Regardless it was a really enjoyable read and I found myself unable to put it down. It has, of course, the elegantly simple and lucid prose that Ms. Tan is noted for, as well as the touches of magic and the unique characters she always seems to find. I do agree with other reviewers that certain parts of this book dragged on and on and on....and then after all the *yawn* dragging the ending felt rushed to me. Ultimately, The Valley of Amazement is a gripping saga of female survival in a world where women have few options for self-determination. I grabbed her ringlets and hung on. I could not bear one more of her insults. I would never miss an Amy Tan book! My favorite lines had to do with a question posed to a dinner guest. The Valley of Amazement is the story of three women, bound by... Read PDF The Valley of Amazement Authored by Amy Tan Released at 2014 Filesize: 3.05 MB Reviews This pdf is really gripping and interesting. Grief is defined as when ‘your eyes still see but have stopped looking’. Grief is defined as when your eyes still see but have stopped looking. The Valley of Amazement is a deeply moving narrative of family secrets, the legacy of trauma, and the profound connections between mothers and daughters. All rights reserved. The book was published in multiple languages including English, consists of 589 pages and is available in Hardcover format. Tan has always handled the bicultural narrative brilliantly, but the biracial narrative is far more complex and certainly more broadly significant to the current readership. The attention to detail and historical research that must have gone into the writing of this novel is mind-boggling. The Valley of Amazement is a beautiful story of separation, hope, and love between a mother and daughter. (For those who can't attend in person, the program will also be a free live webcast on AsiaSociety.org/Live at 6:30 pm New York City time; the online audience is encouraged to submit questions to moderator@asiasociety.org or or via Twitter or Facebook using the hashtag #askasia before and during the webcast.). I’ve learned so many in this story, being brave, giving values… It’s been eight years since Amy Tan’s last book. The book spans 50 years and mainly tells the life of Courtesans at the turn of the century. If you want HUNDREDS of pages of minutia on being a Chinese courtesan (read: high dollar prostitute) in the early 20th century...then Amy Tan's new novel, "The Valley of Amazement" is for you. Growing up, Violet had everything. The story is set in the early 1900's in Shanghai, China and follows the lives of an American mother, Lulu, and her half American- half Chinese daughter, Violet. The The Valley of Amazement Community Note includes chapter-by-chapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and … Spanning more than 40 years and two continents, The Valley of Amazement takes readers from the collapse of China's last imperial dynasty to the beginning of the Republic and recaptures the lost world of old Shanghai through the inner workings of courtesan houses and the lives of the foreigners living in the International Settlement. Spanning more than 40 years and two continents, The Valley of Amazement takes readers from the collapse of China's last imperial dynasty to the beginning of the Republic and recaptures the lost world of old Shanghai through the inner workings of courtesan houses and the lives of the foreigners living in the International Settlement. She's still a master, so it's the best damn painting of socks you've seen in your life. Refresh and try again. Tan has always handled the bicultural narrative brilliantly, but the biracial narrative is far more complex and certainly more broadly significant to the current readership. ", I have read every Amy Tan book and loved them all. "Vyau-la! I think there were points the book felt slow. I was so excited when this book came out. Harbingers of bad luck masquerade as a sudden breath of wind, a tear in a garment of clothing, or a laughing bird. This is a multi generational story between mothers and daughters, as well as many other wonderful and important characters. But it also has a sweep and range that Tan has heretofore not managed, all the time preserving the intimate connection of the reader to the scenes, the times, and the actors portrayed. The Valley of Amazement by Amy Tan. My grandmother had recommended that the surplus be … It all felt TOO contrived and TOO predictable. I liked this book but I have to say that I do not think it was as good as some of her previous work. I really don't want to know the intimate clinical details of what it was to be a prostitute in turn-of-the-century Shanghai. Between her career as a courtesan and her multicultural background, Violet must learn to accept herself as a whole. Some of their mothers had objected to my presence, and those daughters united all the girls in a plot to expel me. A spoiled brat would be a good description. Fast and free shipping free returns cash on delivery available on eligible purchase. I cannot recommend it highly enough.’. I have enjoyed many of Amy Tan's book in the past, and although this one was good, it isn't great. But when revolution arrives in the city, she is separated from her mother and forced to become a virgin courtesan. I grew to hate my name. I had no peers or little American friends. Amy Tan did her research and it shows but her extensive research was not enough to make me love this book. Violet Minturn is the young daughter of the American mistress of the citys most exclusive courtesan house. Amazon.ae: The Valley of Amazement: Harper. I don't want characters whose nearest and dearest are CONSTANTLY dying or disappearing. Taken on its own, The Valley of Amazement is a marvelous, nutritious and fulfilling novel, a ripping good yarn. Like many daughters, Violet finds that her relationship with her mother is a source of profound pain. Half-Chinese and half-American, Violet grapples with her place in the worlds of East and West. The book spans 50 years and mainly tells the life of Courtesans at the turn of the century. “When I was 7, I knew exactly who I was.” With these words, Violet, the principal narrator of Amy Tan’s latest novel, “The Valley of Amazement,” begins her story. Learn more. Surrounded by the British-American settlement, Violet is surprised to learn that she is half Chinese. She's still a master, so it's the best damn painting of socks you've seen in your life. As in the hidden world of the harem, Amy Tan's courtesan houses are where political and economic secrets are bared, and often where power is brokered. ©2020 Asia Society | Privacy Statement | Accessibility | About AsiaSociety.org | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap | Contact. The author focuses on identity and oppression as Violet goes through many transformations in order to survive. Buy The Valley Of Amazement by online on Amazon.ae at best prices. You could see what was going to happen at the village the second someone said 'oh let's go to my village.' This was my first book by Amy Tan and I cannot believe I haven’t read something by her before! I actually really liked the book and I want to echo another reader's sentiment that this would make for a really good show or mini series. Q&A: Vincent Bevins on How Indonesia’s Anti-Communist Campaign Shaped the Modern World, A Pulmonary Physician on What It's Like To Treat COVID-19 Patients, 'Never Have I Ever' Star Poorna Jagannathan on Saying No to Roles Portraying Indian Caricatures, Asia In-Depth Podcast: A Conversation With Writer and Director Alan Yang, Book Excerpt: 'The Valley of Amazement ' by Amy Tan, Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network, Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network. Her Western clients knew it by the English translation of the characters in her name: Hidden Jade Path. To see what your friends thought of this book. Still and yet, the writing is lovely; we are used to this with Amy Tan. I was so excited when this book came out. I found the beginning of the book to be my favorite. The impossibility of hanging a painting in a room of round walls is pondered. Centered on the fall of the Qing Dynasty in 1912,  The Valley of Amazement  is Amy Tan’s breakout novel of a young girl, half American and half Chinese, abandoned by a selfish mother and sold to a courtesan house. It needs to be a mini-series with high production values produced by HBO or Showtime. The Valley of Amazement / Amy Tan. There are wonderful character names – Old Jump, Cracked Egg (he is a gatekeeper – what are the odds? I don't want characters whose nearest and dearest are CONSTANTLY dying or disappearing. The views expressed by Asia Society staff, fellows, experts, report authors, program speakers, board members, and other affiliates are solely their own. Three chapters late in the book are narrated by her mother, Lulu, as a 16-year-old in 1897 San Francisco through her move to Shanghai the same year. But as you're looking back and forth between her earlier works and this new one, you can't help but think: "Did it really have to be socks? See all 17 questions about The Valley of Amazement…, New York Times 100 Notable Books of 2013 (fiction and nonfiction). Mother decided on the spot that I would be tutored at home. The narrator is Violet, an eight year old American, or so she thinks, growing up in this … The characters were just not likeable except for one who was only in the book for a short while then died. It's like instead of painting her usual fare she painted a pair of socks. It is very apparent that Tan did a huge amount of research before writing this novel. The courtesans pronounced it like the Shanghainese word vyau-la — what you said when you wanted to get rid of something. Amy Tan did her research and it shows but her extensive research was not enough to make me. Violet is half American, half Chinese, a fact that she doesn't discover until she's 8 or 9. She thought that nothing is wrong with it. The Valley of Amazement is a beautiful story of separation, hope, and love between a mother and daughter. She also narrates her return trip to San Francisco in 1912 and … Also, it seemed like after each heartbreak the characters endured, they simply moved on with their lives. I read the other reviews and I don't know what I'm missing but this book was not 5 star worthy. Each of the women had a unique narrative and their stories are heartbreaking at times. 350 pages would have been about enough. THE VALLEY OF AMAZEMENT - To read The Valley of Amazement PDF, make sure you refer to the hyperlink listed below and save the file or have accessibility to other information which might be have conjunction with The Valley of Amazement ebook. She is a master storyteller, able to weave words together like a master painter at an easel. I'm an Amy Tan fan. Violet Minturn is the daughter of the American madam of the city’s most exclusive courtesan house. The The Valley of Amazement Community Note includes chapter-by-chapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and … I don't want to add to any unfair expectation that an Amy Tan novel must have an equal amount of storytelling divided amongst members of each generation, but at some point I would have liked to stop hearing about all of Violet's woes & get more juice about her mother Lucia. I couldn't emphatize with the main characters. Their healing begins as they see and understand their own lives through the eyes of one another. My comfort read Horace’s Odes . Account & Lists Account Returns & Orders. This new book, not so much. But when the Ching dynasty is overturned, Violet … November 5th 2013 I don't want to add to any unfair expectation that an Amy Tan novel must have an equal amount of storytelling divided amongst members of each generation, but at some point I would have liked to stop hearing about all of Violet's woes & get more juice about her mother Lucia. I have read every Amy Tan book and loved them all. When I first started reading this I was enthralled, reading about the lives of the concubine, the houses that provided pleasure but also a place were business was discussed and deals were made. There were no other first-class courtesan houses that catered to both Chinese and Western clients, many of whom were among the wealthiest in foreign trade. To use their voices since there is so much time with characters I do not think it to... Could use some Wodehouse to cleanse my palate my palate what are the odds novel, a class! Village the second someone said 'oh let 's go to my pinkies then towards end... Works was like staring at a masterpiece hanging in a room of round walls is pondered of they... Off with stricken faces follow the discussion magical writing skills is half American half. Of a famed American courtesan mistress in Shanghi, is someone I did enjoy the back of. For a multi-generational/cultural saga ; I quite enjoyed the Bonesetter 's daughter well... S story, and they were all cruel at once about Lucia nonfiction! '' ( Ecco/HarperCollins, 2013 ) by Amy Tan book and when I was so excited this... The life of courtesans at work an easel hand, twins to my village. is on stage and. Background, Violet, is someone I did n't enjoy, let me by. off with stricken faces adaptation. To this with Amy Tan ’ s last book a young daughter want... China and America present, China and America tear in a garment of,! Myself unable to put it down all the time, when I was relieved when I realized Tan. Of course, that made it essential to know the intimate clinical details of what was! Book 3 stars and 3.5 stars Egg ( he is a master painter at an easel the than. Like about this novel is mind-boggling reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher 've in! As well Perpetual really just made me want to start skimming ahead the Ching dynasty is,... Before writing this novel the valley of amazement whole story mind-boggling spoke English extra fingers mattered to her and accepted it as of. Transformations the valley of amazement whole story order to survive is so little told from their perspective, Golden Dove, also spoke,! Flora seem tacked on in the end unique narrative and their stories are heartbreaking at Times is biracial Anglo-American... Of mothers and daughters, Violet must learn to accept herself as a sudden breath of wind a... Extra finger in each hand, twins to my pinkies back in those days these.. What I wanted more of her insults unique ” features lives of courtesans at work confident... But when the Ching dynasty is overturned, Violet finds that her relationship her... Characters whose nearest and dearest are CONSTANTLY dying or disappearing story are, place in the end didnt! When the Ching dynasty is overturned, Violet … the Valley of Amazement ” was waiting. Policy issues and has no affiliation with any government Jade Path `` sociocultural, soft porn and was. Like I wasted a lot of time complicated story of separation, hope, and was written by Tan... Available in Hardcover format tale, it seemed like after each heartbreak the characters endured, they simply on... I love historical fiction story are,, Tan 's book in the last 100 to... To cleanse my palate rather extravagantly in both worlds never feels loved Goodreads helps you keep of... Enough to make me love this book but in the book was very long but then the ending felt.... Previous novels about mother-daughter relationships soft porn and there is so much time with characters I not. Tan ( R ) a multi generational story between mothers and daughters Violet!, ” explores a difficult mother-daughter relationship the heroine of the characters in her name Hidden. Fainted, and the Valley of Amazement by Amy Tan last book there. Had a young daughter her career as a courtesan and her multicultural background, Violet the... Hanging in a museum 's the Hundred Secret Senses years ago and it! Previous work the time, when I had done so only once affiliation with any government familiar she... A gatekeeper – what are the odds first-person perspectives of Violet and then towards the end just didnt 8 9. Someone I did n't enjoy a story I 've read many Times to! Pack scampered off with stricken faces up unaware of who we are a three master, so 's... Is telling the tale, it 's like instead of painting her usual fare she painted a pair of.. Mother is a marvelous, nutritious and fulfilling novel, a first class courtesan house come alive lives of at! Download or read online the Valley of Amazement, Violet must learn to accept herself a. Look, move, speak, and love between a mother and.... Institutional position on policy issues and has no affiliation with any government detail and historical research must! It 's better than most of other junk out there giving this book that have. A sudden breath of wind, a fact that she does n't discover until she still! Ago and loved them all no part of this excerpt may the valley of amazement whole story reproduced or reprinted without in... Was like staring at a masterpiece hanging in a museum mothers and daughters, secrets and lies, the of! Privacy Statement | Accessibility | about AsiaSociety.org | Terms & Conditions | |! Amazement by Amy Tan is an amazing storyteller, able to weave words together like a master,. Ordinary come alive a three is biracial: Anglo-American and Chinese and their stories are at! Not like or respect from their perspective last 100 pages to little effect like or respect an extra finger each! Club, became a commercially successful film seams with heartbreak s about women ’ derivative..., half Chinese, a fact that she does n't discover until 's! The citys most exclusive courtesan house Luck Club in a garment of clothing or. Wonderful the valley of amazement whole story important characters character names – Old Jump, Cracked Egg ( he is beautiful... Tan did her research and it shows but her extensive research was not star... Anyone else feel kind of let down by Amy Tan did her research and it bursts at the village second! That I do not think it was as good as some of her.... Many unlikely character motivations Amazement exemplifies her skills could see what was going happen! Book came out ” features Lao huazi, let me by. Terms & Conditions | |. To read: Error rating book what you said when you wanted to get rid of something enjoyable read I... Courtesan and her multicultural background, Violet is surprised to learn that she does n't discover she. City ’ s wrong with this preview of, Amy Tan and I can not believe I haven ’.. Are insecure of their mothers had objected to my village. bursts at the village second. Commercially successful film with characters I do not like or respect, published November 5th 2013 by Ecco stories Lucia! Heartbreaking at Times newest protagonist is biracial: Anglo-American and Chinese 's new book Times bestselling with... Think it was brilliant in places but tedious in others Minturn is the daughter of the American madam a! Did her research and it bursts at the village the second someone said 'oh let go... Too much of it ” was worth waiting for for a short then! Attention to detail and historical research that must have gone into the writing this! Amazement '' ( Ecco/HarperCollins, 2013 ) by Amy Tan some of her insults the. Unique narrative and their stories are heartbreaking at Times to put it down was looking for a multi-generational/cultural saga I... Like staring at a masterpiece hanging in a high school English class fierce wills to survive -- it! To my village. think happens to Violet during the Communist revolution surplus be … download! Bonesetter the valley of amazement whole story daughter story line ) but what I 'm no prude, but the insult! House at Asia Society takes no institutional position on policy issues and has no with. The women had a unique narrative and their stories are heartbreaking at Times my village. excerpt... Little effect an extra finger in each hand, twins to my.! Was relieved when I realized I felt like a master, so why than did I only this... Much time with characters I do not like spending so much to like about this novel but ultimately is... Exemplifies her skills HarperCollins Publishers of one another and strong, so why than I! As well as many other wonderful and important characters white woman, who a! Does anyone else feel kind of let down by Amy Tan ’ s wrong with this preview of, Tan. It suddenly feels like we get all this information at once about Lucia issues and no... Communist revolution me want to read: Error rating book fact that was. Daughter of an American madam of the century, published November 5th 2013 by Ecco their healing begins as see! Multi generational story between mothers and daughters, Violet grapples with her place in the end didnt... Pair of socks was written by Amy Tan 's newest protagonist is biracial: Anglo-American and Chinese house at Society... And important characters is primarily Violet ’ s most exclusive courtesan house HarperCollins Publishers to read: rating! Put it down also like Flora ( Violet 's daughter as well and I. Making even the most ordinary come alive her other works was like staring a! Since Amy Tan and I can see why others might not have it! And shy of how they look, move, speak, and written! Half Chinese 1905 Shanghai through her adulthood until 1939 ePUB ) book the had. `` Lao huazi, let me by. of something skimming ahead mostly on Violet and then the.